So, theres been a lot of chatter over recent weeks about Brain Computer Interfacing since Tan Le’s TED talk on the Emotiv which resulted in the emotiv site being overloaded with hits and the letters “B, C and I” becoming familiar to fellow geeks the world over. The talk is mostly a marketing pitch so as I’m currently (amateur that I may be) involved in some BCI research myself I figured I’d give a little explanation of whats going on here… 

 

Brain Computer Interfacing is not a new discovery but is currently emerging as a practical option for clinical treatment of “locked in syndrome”. The claims made by Emotiv however that the company has made a discovery that allows BCI to be released on the consumer market for gaming purposes are therefore intriguing. A major problem for decoding the EEG signals that the  BCI relies upon is that the electrical signal the brain gives off is very weak and must travel through both skull and tissue. Emotiv claims it’s “breakthrough was to create an algorithm that unfolds the cortex so that we can map the signals closer to it’s source and therefore making it capable of working across a mass population“. 

mans brain The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble?

The surface of the brain is folded, and the signals it gives off are complex and extremely distorted (teehee)

This currently hasn’t really been achieved by the army of BCI researchers working in institutions around the world so if true it is a genuine breakthrough that could have positive implications for sufferers of many degenerate brain disease patients and paralysis patients as well of course as the shock and awe of gamers everywhere. This finding however hasn’t been published in any journals to date, this should ring a number of alarm bells. 

The second eye brow raiser is that even relatively old EEG equipment costs tens of thousands of dollars and requires close contact between fine metal electrodes which must be carefully placed exactly on top of very precise areas of the scalp and the signal to be conducted with conductive gel in an intricate and time consuming process. Emotiv claim that their system is able to perform what appear to be better results than the state of the art in BCI with only dry electrodes and without any real care in the electrode placement. 

Another problem with the portrayal of the emotive device is that it seems to operate very differently from traditional cursor control BCI systems. Cursor control generally requires motor imagery. This means imagining a movement in a part of your body which “lights up” a part of your brain and programming a computer to recognise when you are imagining this movement. This requires pinpointing signals from a part of the brain called the motor cortex… 

motorcortex1 The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble?Besides being relatively small, this problem is made worse by the fact that the nerves that send and receive motor information around the body are not evenly distributed. This if you have not seen it before is called a homunculus and is the widely regarded and long held model of how psychologists believe the motor system is distrbuted proportionally around the body (this is why contemporary BCIs revolve around imagined hand movement)… 

3d homunculus The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble? 

if this were to be mapped over the surface of the brain it would to the best of our knowledge resemble something like this…homunculus The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble? 

And just for fun recent research has even suggested that a sensory homunculus may even look a bit more like this… 

penile homunculus The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble? 

My sincere apologies for inflicting that last image on you. No comment on the implications of that with regard to BCI though, just no, final answer. 

My point is that BCI systems as they are known today require us to imagine things that can  be very hard to identify alone let alone program a computer to decode so the process as it stands is considerably more complicated than imagining a computer doing something and “poof” it happening. Unfortunately the signals given off when we think are far more complex than any TV or radio signal and can’t be decoded in the same way. I’m not saying it will forever be impossible just that development will take time, progress will be made in baby steps and we may well be far further behind the point in the developmental process than this video suggests we are. It would be a great shame for the importance of future research to be diminished by a popular perception that “someone else did all that years ago”. I really don’t want to throw sand on anyones bonfire I just believe you have the right to be well informed. 

These three factors that I mentioned, in combination with a lack of any published work make myself and all of the experts I have spoken to, very reluctant to believe that this device will prove as effective as it is billed. The main concern of the critics to date is that the emotiv may actually use facial muscle movements rather than brain waves to provide the minimal control it allows. This would make the headset a rather obscure and ineffective way of picking up these signals (which would be EMG signals). One professor of Engineering working within the BCI field who I won’t name has described such devices as “Head Computer Interfaces rather than Brain Computer Interfaces”. We won’t know either way until someone does a controlled study and makes the results public. If the critics are wrong however this will come to be seen as a commercial breakthrough of epic proportions. 

eureka The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble?Regardless of whether the discoveries made by Emotiv are as grand as they sound or not the team at Emotiv certainly deserve credit for their work so far, their product is a step towards the hopes and dreams of all that have stepped foot in the field and we are all looking forward to seeing some published results by the company and hearing how this research develops. 

Until then however, I won’t be splashing out the the $500 (just slashed from $2500) for the research edition of the product and nor will I be buying the somewhat cheaper consumer model just yet. I will however be keeping a close eye on the progress of this product as it does seem to be the most advanced product in a field just gagging for it’s bubble to burst. 

For the record, I am only just beginning to dip my toe in to the deep dark lake that is this field so BIG respect to Emotiv for what they have achieved and all the other people working on mind bending projects like this. If I have learned one thing from seeing inside this field of research it is that it is going to be a very hard nut to crack. 

If you are interested in this product this is their site and there is an interesting though now somewhat dead public google wave for users and developers of the emotiv product here.

Return to Neurobonkers.com The Emotiv Empoc... Bursting the BCI Bubble?
Tagged with:
 
  • http://neuromancy.wordpress.com Neuromancy

    I love the idea of BCI, but I was similarly amazed to see Emotiv being marketed as so advanced. I played on a machine at SfN2008, but that was just based on relative stregnths of different frequency bands.

    P.S. I think the second ugly dude is a sensory homunculus, unless he can do things with…particular body parts…that I don’t think I can do. I’d love to have a model sensory and motor homunculus for my desk, I think I’d have to buy him little shorts though!

    • Neurobonkers

      HAHA! I’m pretty sure your right – fixed. Thanks for the feedback, I’ll look in to it when I have a minute ;-) I believe the London Natural History Museum has a range, thats where the picture is taken from!

  • Pingback: Man’s Brain….. « Punjapit

  • http://www.universalmediaman.nl Universal Mediaman

    And what do you think of the Mindset from company Neurosky?

    • Neurobonkers

      I think research is always a good thing and we can’t expect these companies not to work hard to sell their products. This just needs to be countered with critical review. At the moment I think there is far more scope for biofeedback to be used by the layperson for relaxation than BCI has for the purposes of gaming so Neurosky may well be on to something.

  • http://www.medicalbillinginfoblog.com medical billing

    this post is very usefull thx!

  • http://www.aparadekto.com aparadekto

    Hey, I can’t view your site properly within Opera, I actually hope you look into fixing this.

  • http://www.sklepdzieci.com foteliki samochodowe dla dzieci

    Thanks For This Blog, was added to my bookmarks.

  • http://www.legalsoundz.com Legalsounds

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

  • http://www.rachunkowe24.sejny.pl/2010/05/28/nad-morzem-2/ Andrew A. Sailer

    I start to dislike this spam from writing here someones on the forums… Your blog looks as free without… Would You like to serve me and express to all the method you are using if You’re fighting against the spamers? TX

  • http://www.youtube.com/redirect?q=www.dartproshop.com/soft-tip-darts-c-81.html Shae Mozer

    I found your blog on yahoo. I think it’s pretty cool.

  • http://wowcatalevel.weebly.com/ Marceline Helscher

    Outstanding post, I conceive blog owners should acquire a lot from this blog its very user pleasant.

  • http://ematio.nl matio

    Interesting article and one which should be more widely known about in my view. Your level of detail is good and the clarity of writing is excellent. I have bookmarked it for you so that others will be able to see what you have to say.

  • http://rankingdomination.net serp ranking

    Hello there! I really enjoy reading your blog! If you keep making amazing posts like this I will come back every day to keep reading.

  • http://wolffenbuttel-huussen.nl/phbBB/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=3122 Dorian Barnt

    I’d be inclined to cut a deal with you here. Which is not something I typically do! I really like reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to speak my mind!

  • http://script-review.com Delbert Yanchik

    I was very tickled to stumble across this site.I wanted to thank you for this Fascinating blog!! I truly enjoyed every small little bit of it and I have you favorited to take a look at new stories you publish.

  • http://www.multivitamins.myvillagegreen.com/index.html North West Pharmacy

    That was a wonderful post! Thanks for sharing your knowledge with us! I hope to read more of your post which is very informative and useful to all the readers. I salute writers like you for doing a great job!

  • http://www.emotiv.com/ neural interface

    Hi Friends. This is Rasheed Ahmed from India. I’m pursuing final year Computer Science Egg. Check out my Blog completely and leave your comments about my blog. The process, these thought-controlled sensors are inspiring innovations that, for instance, allow you to call someone on your phone by simply thinking about them. Thanks for visiting my Blog…! Have a Nice Day……………!
    neural interface

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:


Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Visit our friends!

A few highly recommended friends...